I bought these two in Rosette succulents, pretty much every single one was on great condition! I ended up leaving them in their nursery pots because I was waiting for the soil. After a week I noticed a couple had black leaves on the bottom like they were rotting while others were fine? I ended up taking them out and noticed the soil was still moist, now this had never happened with harddy before so I figured during shipping it didn't completely dry out. I let them dry out for a day and planted they are doing great! I contacted Kelley from harddy when I noticed the black leaves. She offered to replace but they are doing really great to biggy! They did replace my blue chalk sticks free of charge from my very first order! I love harddy. My go to online succulent nursery!